Dams and Weirs

Well, it's that time of year again, time to renew the web hosting. And for those of you that don't know, that has become a lot more expensive than it used to be. Fifty dollars a year is now several hundred. Not to mention the price of domain names has gone up ten-fold.

And I just found out that the nice folks at PayPal disabled all my Support buttons, and I never got a notice (although that may be my fault.) In any case, it is all working again now, so if you would like to make a small donation to help defray these costs, it would be greatly appreciated.

A weir or low-head dam is a barrier across the width of a river that alters the flow characteristics of water and usually results in a change in the height of the river level. Weirs are also used to control the flow of water for outlets of lakes, ponds, and reservoirs. There are many weir designs, but commonly water flows freely over the top of the weir crest before cascading down to a lower level.

Even though the water around weirs can often appear relatively calm, they can be extremely dangerous places to boat, swim, or wade, as the circulation patterns on the downstream side - typically called a hydraulic jump - can submerge a person indefinitely. This phenomenon is so well known to canoeists, kayakers, and others who spend time on rivers that they even have a rueful name for weirs: "drowning machines".

There are dozens of these structures across the state, and most of them are not marked on maps. For trip planning, I have marked as many as I can find, except for the obvious ones that create lakes which are easily spotted even if they are not marked. Most of New Jersey's navigable waterways, lakes and ponds are artificially created.

https://practical.engineering/blog/2019/3/16/drowning-machine-the-dangers-of-low-head-dams

The Ohio DNR recommends that a victim should "tuck the chin down, draw the knees up to the chest with arms wrapped around them. Hopefully, conditions will be such that the current will push the victim along the bed of the river until swept beyond the boil line and released by the hydraulic." The Pennsylvania State Police also recommends to victims, "curl up, dive to the bottom, and swim or crawl downstream". As the hydraulic jump entrains air, the buoyancy of the water between the dam and boil line will be reduced by upward of 30%,* and if a victim is unable to float, escape at the base of the dam may be the only option for survival.

* In other words, your pfd is not going to save you!

While it is actually pretty hard to go over the top of most small dams, it is often easy to approach the bottom. The danger is more for swimmers than boaters, but if you fall out of the boat, you become a swimmer. So just stay away from these places.

Island Farm Weir, Bridgewater, New Jersey

The Island Farm Weir on the Raritan River drowned several people
( 40.54290, -74.56613 )

Completion of the Island Farm Weir on the Raritan River occurred in October 1995. The Raritan River was classified by New Jersey as being suitable for recreational uses, including boating. Nevertheless, neither the owner, engineer, or the local government was inclined to install warning signs on the landings for boaters. Six months later, on April 12, 1996, a recreational canoeist paddled over the dam crest and was drowned in the recirculation flow of the reverse roller, while attempting to rescue his comrade, who had capsized. The river discharge on this date was 2,000 cfs over the 200-foot-long dam that was 8 feet high. The unit discharge was 10 cfs per foot. Following a total of four drownings, the dam was retrofitted to satisfactorily eliminate the reverse roller characteristic.

Even though the dam was 8 feet high, the hydraulic drop across the dam, from upstream to downstream, was only 2.8 feet, due to the stilling basin depth and the high tailwater conditions. At the crest of the dam, the velocity was 7 fps, with a depth of 1.55 feet. Meanwhile, where the overflow jet met the downstream pool, the velocity had increased to over 13 fps, with a Froude number of 2.8.

Figure 3 illustrates the dam and hydraulic characteristics at the time of the drowning and shows the length of the reverse roller at 30 feet, with an upstream velocity toward the dam of only a modest 2.0 fps; yet the current was able to trap the victim causing his expiration and the injury of two companions.

Prior to the subject drowning incident, a jet skier went up to the base of the dam where he was trapped and drowned. Then, following the subject event, a local television station was at the Island Farm Weir to do a piece on water hazards. During the filming, a canoeist unexpectedly appeared upstream and paddled over the dam crest. He capsized, his canoe bobbed (sometimes being vertical), and the victim drowned on the evening TV broadcast, his drowning being spectacularly recorded.

The Island Farm Weir was finally retrofitted in 1998 after four drownings in only three years following its construction. The successful retrofit consisted of merely flattening the downstream face of the dam by providing a series of steps to dissipate energy and to eliminate the opportunity for a reverse roller to form below the dam structure.

Island Farm Weir after modification, low flow
Note the fish ladder in the background.

https://damfailures.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/Wright_PublicSafetyLowHead.pdf

Dams, Weirs and Falls
( 40.54520, -74.72257 )

The map above only shows the dams and weirs that might be obstacles. Many more actually create places to go! Flip through the map sources and you'll see just how poorly these structures are recorded. For example, the Island Farm Weir above is on neither the topographic nor the street map.


After Google sent me a bill for their map service, I decided to switch to OpenLayers maps, which are free. And I quickly came to like them better. At first, I thought the satellite imagery was neat, but it turns out that often things are hidden under trees. Also, the coordinates on the satellite imagery are less-than-accurate. Google's street maps are also less-than-accurate, and also less-than-informative, lacking accurate borders and labels ( although they do have lots of advertising! )

As I got the hang of OpenLayers, I started to redo a lot of things and simplify, getting rid of a lot of stuff I had done to make up for the shortcomings of Google Maps. OpenLayers maps look a lot like USGS quadrangles, and don't need a lot of help, just zoom in and there is a wealth of information. Google's maps are also strongly colored, which makes it difficult at times to do anything with them. OpenLayers uses nice muted colors that are easy to write over.

But satellite imagery is still interesting and informative, so I added links to both Google Earth and Bing servers. A great deal of functionality comes from an plugin I wrote to help-out the main maps plugin. I've also made a few changes and bug fixes to that, which I hope the developer will eventually incorporate. The irony of this, for Google anyway, is that the free products are actually much better than the paid ones.

Printed from njkayak.net